← Back to the blog

Group polarization. How disagreement turns into ‘us versus them’

Have you noticed how a conversation about phones can turn into an argument between iPhone and Android users? It starts with battery life or the camera. A little later, everyone is defending their choice as if someone had insulted them personally.

Group polarization. How disagreement turns into ‘us versus them’

Group polarization is the tendency of a group to move further in the direction it was already leaning. When you mostly hear from people who agree with you, you find more reasons to think you’re right. And when an opinion becomes part of your identity, a disagreement can feel like an attack on your group. Moscovici & Zavalloni, 1969 · Iyengar et al., 2012

The same pattern shows up in everyday conversations.

  • In party politics. Two people argue about which party is right. The conversation ends before either looks at what the proposal that affects them actually says.
  • In football. Two fans watch the same play. One sees a clear penalty. The other sees a dive. The colour of the shirt shapes how they read the play.
  • In technology. The conversation turns into “Apple or Samsung?” and we forget to ask what the person who’ll use the phone every day actually needs.
  • With CMS platforms. One person swears by WooCommerce, another by OpenCart. Meanwhile, the shop owner wants to know what maintenance will cost and who can provide support.

How our attention gets redirected

A disagreement can be genuine and still be exploited. Imagine a local council needs to explain why a project is behind schedule. If the public debate turns into an argument about which party cares most about the town, the question that affects everyone gets pushed aside. When will the project be finished, and who is responsible for the delay?

Communication researchers have spent decades studying how the visibility of an issue affects how important we think it is. Social media also gives people a reason to turn up the heat. In a study of political posts in the United States, references to the opposing side were associated with more shares. An argument can grow on its own, and anyone looking to change the subject finds a dispute that’s already drawing attention. McCombs & Shaw, 1972 · Rathje et al., 2021

Next time I feel the urge to reply in defence of “my side”, it’s worth pausing for a moment. What were we talking about before we started picking sides?